Empathy & Compassion Are Both Important, But They're Not The Same—Here's How

Empathy and compassion are both factors that influence our relationships, life satisfaction, and ultimately, overall wellbeing. You might think of them as synonymous, but it would be more accurate to think of them like two sides of them same coin—and one of those sides is actually better for your health than the other.

Empathy is defined by the Oxford Dictionary as "the ability to understand and share the feelings of another." As therapist Babita Spinelli, L.P., tells mindbodygreen, it involves putting yourself in someone else's shoes, imagining how they might feel, and experiencing a sense of resonance with their emotions.

"Empathy allows you to connect with others on an emotional level and recognize their perspectives, [such as] a parent feeling the disappointment or sadness of their child losing a game or struggling with a challenge," she explains.

And as licensed clinical psychologist Bruce L. Thiessen, Ph.D., previously told mindbodygreen, "When one expresses empathy, one draws upon personal experience in relating to another person in the midst of a similar experience or hardship," adding that an example of an empathetic statement might be, I also have recently lost a loved one and know what it feels like to experience that deep sense of sorrow and grief."

The caveat with empathy, however, is that it can quickly turn toxic when left unchecked. As one 2014 study on empathy published in the journal Current Biology1 explains, "In empathy, one feels with someone, but one does not confuse oneself with the other; that is, one still knows that the emotion one resonates with is the emotion of another. If this self–other distinction is not present, we speak of emotion contagion."

When emotion contagion happens, we can unwittingly take on the emotions of others—for better or worse. So if your coworker or partner is in a bad mood, you might start to feel that bad mood creep up on you too.

Compassion is defined by the Oxford Dictionary as "sympathetic pity and concern for the sufferings or misfortunes of others."

As Spinelli explains, compassion goes beyond empathy in that it involves feeling a deep concern and a desire to alleviate someone's suffering. "Compassion is characterized by a genuine sense of care, kindness, and a willingness to take action to help others in need," she adds.

And according to Thiessen, both empathy and sympathy, when coming from a place of sincerity, are sensations and open expressions of compassion. He says that compassion can come out of empathy, typically when there's a sharing of similar experiences with another person—but compassion from sympathy can be just as useful.

"For example," he notes, "the act of researching the types of suffering experienced by an abused child might increase a person's sympathy for abused children, regardless of whether or not the researching party had ever been a victim of child abuse."

So, what's the difference between the two? According to Spinelli, while empathy and compassion are closely related and can work in tandem when it comes to understanding and relating to the emotions and experiences of others, empathy focuses on understanding and sharing those emotions, while compassion extends sympathy by adding a proactive and caring response to suffering.

In this way, according to Thiessen, this sense of commonality with others is the key differentiator between the two. For instance, you could be compassionate for another's suffering without necessarily empathizing, and vice versa, you could feel empathy for someone's suffering without necessarily being compassionate about it.

In fact, as recent research published in the journal Emotion2 explores, compassion appears to reign supreme when it comes to how empathy versus compassion impact our health. As the study authors explain, too much empathy can be hard on your health, while compassion seems to elevate it.

"Empathic people, controlling for compassion, often use self-focused language and write about negative feelings, social isolation, and feeling overwhelmed," they write. "Compassionate people, controlling for empathy, often use other-focused language and write about positive feelings and social connections."

This research ultimately highlights that high empathy without compassion is related to negative health outcomes, while high compassion without empathy is related to positive health outcomes, positive lifestyle choices, and charitable giving. "Such findings favor an approach to moral motivation that is grounded in compassion rather than empathy," the study authors add.

One of the best ways to cultivate more compassion for others is to be more compassion with yourself. As physician and New York Times bestselling author of Mind Over Medicine, Lissa Rankin, M.D. previously wrote for mindbodygreen, "As long as you have an inner general beating you up for your inevitable imperfections, you’ll find it difficult to be compassionate with others when they reveal their humanness."

Along with nurturing your relationship with yourself, another way to cultivate compassion for others is by practicing generous listening. Coined by Rachel Naomi Remen, M.D., an expert in integrative medicine and relationship centered care, the practice of generous listening can be a gateway to compassion and a tool for healing.

According to her, “Listening creates a holy silence. When you listen generously to people, they can hear truth in themselves, often for the first time. And in the silence of listening, you can know yourself in everyone. Eventually, you may be able to hear, in everyone and beyond everyone, the unseen singing softly to itself and to you.”

It's important to remember that compassionate kindness does not equate to people-pleasing, which is particularly notable here, as those with a high degree of empathy can get into the habit of managing others' emotions (as a way to manage their own).

As Rankin explains, "Kindness doesn’t mean selling out what’s true for you in order to make someone else feel good. Authentic kindness stems from a place of wholeness within, where there is no separation between the giver and the receiver." She adds that whether you’re giving gifts, granting forgiveness, or showing someone love, "true kindness blesses you as much as it does the one you're serving."